Sections
For Grades and Wisdom First
The following essay first appeared as an article in Alvaro de Vicente’s Substack publication, Men in the Making. For more articles like this one, you can visit his page here. Subscribe to the publication to stay up-to-date on Alvaro’s writing.
This essay is part of a series entitled “Life Prep.”
So far, we have discussed high school success in general, as well as what this means for your son’s physical growth during his high school years in particular. We have considered the corpus sanum; now it is time to look more closely at the mens sana.

The typical ways to define academic success in the setting of a formal school are grades and admission to the next desired academic level, the latter holding more importance in many people’s minds.
Measuring academic success merely by good grades and institutional outcomes, however, sets up an unhelpfully limited standard, one which may even deform a student. Locating academic success in grades is potentially deformative because it mistakes a feedback tool for the goal to which the feedback ought to be ordered. Intellectual formation is about developing the cognitive capacities that will enable a student to encounter the truth and to live well. The curriculum serves this end: it is an organized way for a school to introduce students to more of reality than they would encounter if left to their own devices. And grades are a way of communicating to students and parents how a student is progressing through the curriculum.
The goal is wisdom, broadly conceived, not what letters appear on a transcript. And a student who cares disproportionately much about grades is often a student who cares disproportionately little about the reality the curriculum presents. Such a student has let the academic process mold him into an intellectual utilitarian.
The Benefit of Grades
At the same time, a student should care about his grades. Indeed, the opposite extreme—the student who cares about grades too little—can also find his academic experience deformative. Such disinterest is often laziness masked as stoic superiority. School is, after all, his work for the time being, and so he ought to do it as well as he can. By neglecting it, he wastes an opportunity to learn and prepare to become an excellent professional, does an injustice to his parents by failing to take advantage of the opportunities they provide, and develops poor professional habits.
We want students to care about grades enough to pursue them seriously—as a lower limit. And we want students who care more about the truth, so that in sincerely pursuing it, they transcend the grade itself. In this way, school becomes truly beneficial: they grow in their ambition for professional excellence, properly ordering that drive so that it subserves the pursuit of wisdom itself.
Rightly understood, grades can serve the deeper aim of intellectual formation by being what Vanderbilt professor Dr. Arthur Brooks calls proxy goals. Such goals, Brooks explains, though not the final end themselves, give one a concrete direction. The star above Bethlehem, though not the final destination of the Magi, helped guide them to the Christ child because it was visible even from a distance. So, too, grades can provide a short-term, tangible goal for a student, one that, if followed well, leads him somewhere better than itself.
The Grade Equation
All of this is by way of philosophical introduction. What does it mean in practice? Here is a helpful way to think about grades. A grade is the output of an equation:
Grades = intellectual ability + time + habits/tactics + effort
Someone who is extremely intelligent may do very well in school with little studying, few habits, and almost imperceptible effort. I once asked a brilliant friend of mine, who had graduated at the top of his class from an elite university, if he would give a study habits class to a group of high school freshmen. With some degree of panic in his voice, he told me he couldn’t. He felt incompetent to do so. He had never really studied in school and therefore had no study habits to share, even with freshmen in high school. There are very few human beings like this man. And even ability is not entirely fixed; it grows with good habits and serious work. Still, the vast majority of students need to look to the other three factors in the equation to improve their grades.
Time Is a Treasure
Time is a treasure, and like any treasure, it should be spent deliberately. Many high school and college students would do better academically if they simply spent a little more time studying.
When helping someone achieve academic success, I think it is a good strategy to first understand how much time he is devoting to his studies. I often ask my students to track in their assignment notebooks how much time they spend studying each discipline. We can then determine whether they need to spend more time or become more efficient with that time by improving their habits, tactics, and effort. A student needs to spend sufficient time studying before he can become an efficient student.
Spend Your Time Well
Habits and tactics are the factors that allow for the most coaching and potential growth. There are many approaches worth teaching. Some are universal: the more external senses you employ, the better you learn the material. Reading aloud and underlining, for example, are generally more effective than simply reading to oneself. Quizzing oneself on the material works better than rereading it. Several shorter study sessions spread over a few days work better than one long session the night before. And a phone left in another room is one less distraction to fight. Other habits will be particular to each student, adapted to his circumstances: his schedule, the classes he is taking, his other activities, and even the makeup of the space in which he studies.
Study habits books and classes are often beneficial. Yet the best way to develop good study habits is likely through a personal conversation with a mentor who knows the student and his circumstances well. Developing good study habits is one of the most beneficial conversations that mentors at The Heights have with their mentees, precisely because it is personal and takes into account the particular circumstances of each student.
The Sticking Point Is the Growth Point
Effort is the factor that depends most on the student himself and is hardest for anyone else in his life to help him with. The student needs to be motivated to apply effort and to develop a high threshold for the discomfort that comes with applying it consistently and meaningfully.
Effort starts in the classroom. A friend of mine, a Division I athlete in college who also worked about 20 hours a week during the school year, once set himself the goal of paying so much attention in every class that he would never have to study. As far as I know, he never quite got there. But he did very well academically, and I am sure he spent less time studying as a result.
Motives Maketh the Man
The point is this: if a student seeks to improve his grades by dedicating more time to his work, improving his habits, and increasing his capacity to apply effort to the task at hand, it will not be only his grades that improve. He will become a better worker—the kind employers want to hire and families can depend on. Even so, such a student may still be doing all of this for the grades and nothing else. This is why the equation helps us understand academic success but is ultimately insufficient: it is missing a term, and it is the most important one.
In addition to becoming a better student through time, habits, and effort, he needs to become a better person through the intention with which he studies. That is what it means to cultivate a mens sana. Ultimately, academic success is not measured by becoming a better student per se, but by becoming a better person in and through one’s studies.
Next in the Series
Read the entire “Life Prep” series. Articles will continue to be added to this collection as the series continues.
About the Author
Alvaro de Vicente
Headmaster of The Heights School and an advisor to hundreds of school leaders, both of start-up schools and established schools seeking to revamp their offerings—especially for boys.